| Author |
Topic  |
|
356FAN
USA
43 Posts |
Posted - February 05 2003 : 07:30:17 AM
I believe that Classic Motor Carriages is out of business ? But have seen several un-started kits for sale and wanted some opinions on the quality of the kits they built and the build process.Besides shorting the VW do I need to build up a frame to mount the kit etc. Also I was curious to know if parts between kit makers are interchangeable not just for Classic Motor Carriages but between other manufactures as well. Thanks 356FAN 356FAN |
meat
USA
992 Posts |
Posted - February 05 2003 : 08:50:26 AM
I don't have any specific experience with the CMC kit, however I did build a speedster from intermeccanica, and helped a neighbor with their car. I don't know how many of the parts are interchangeable, but I can find out for you. I'll check with one of the local manufacturers and post as soon as I know better.Your pal, Meat. 
|
meat
USA
992 Posts |
Posted - February 05 2003 : 4:41:17 PM
Okay...Here's what I found out:First off, you can still get the Speedster kits from Street Beasts, and they have all of the parts necessary to put together the kits. Their web address is: http://streetbeasts.com/Speedster/index.htm It looks like the kit runs about $12,995 (Speedster C). There are other options available, and I do not recommend purchasing from Street Beasts. The kit that I like the most is the one offered by Vintage Speedsters in Hawaiian Gardens, California. It's priced much more attractively ($8,900). I've seen a few of these cars, driven one for a weekend, and it's a very nice, easy to assemble kit. And you can get ahold of Kirk Duncan pretty much any time during business hours ... which is a bit different than how things work at Street Beasts/CMC/Innovative. The address for Vintage is: www.vintagespeedsters.com If you're looking at a used CMC/Street Beasts car, let me know a bit more about it and I'll see what I can do to help you out in your purchase. Your pal, Meat. 
|
stephenbl
64 Posts |
Posted - February 05 2003 : 8:01:10 PM
356 FAN, CMC is out of business, but all their molds and tooling were purchased by Innovative Street Machines. The Speedsters you're seeing advertised are most likely older kits, and are not like the ones you'll see at their website: http://streetbeasts.com/Speedster/index.htm What you'll see at their website is a recently redesigned version. The only real difference is the subframe. The old and new subframes are very similar, with the main difference being that the new version eliminates having to shorten the volkswagon pan by eliminating it, from the front suspension to the rear torsion bar tube. The new version is designed to accept the volkswagon components: The entire front suspension, the old Volkswagon frame from the rear torsion bar rearward(complete with rear suspension, engine, trans, etc), and the brake master cylinder, gas tank, sterring rack. I don't think I've left anything out. The Volkswagon pan is replaced with a fiberglass floor over an improved subframe. This is clearly shown on their website. They felt it was necessary to do this, since rustfree volkswagon frames are getting increasingly harder to find in some area of the country. Replacing the pans of the old beetle chassis is a relatively simple process (you'll need steel cutting tools, and welding equipment), but increasingly, the main tunnel, on which the shifter, handbrake, etc are mounted, are rusted, and this is the majority of the strength of a volkswagon chassis. I haven't had the opportunity to build one of the redesigned Speedsters yet, but I've built about a dozen of the older versions (I worked at an assembly shop before and during my college years). It appears that the effort needed to build the new version is higher than the old. Shortening the VW chassis is the most difficult part in building the older versions. Once again, you'll need metal cutting tools, welders, etc. Often, people have this done by a local metal fabrication shop, etc., and for good reason...it is critical that the chassis remain square, and it must be rewelded by an experienced welder...poor welds here will get you killed. But, once shortened, the body drops directly onto the chassis. The old kit also has a tube frame, but acts to reinforce the VW chassis, and to provide hard points for door hinges, etc. This subframe is already attached to the body. There is still much to do after this, but the only real thing left that might be a challenge is the wiring...luckily, though, the wiring is very simple for this car. To build the new version, it appears you have to cut the middle section out of the VW chassis, and attach it to the new subframe...IMHO, this appears to be more difficult than just shortening the old VW chassis, and installing new pans if needed. So, if you're wanting to get started in the kit car hobby, you've made a good choice. It's always been one of the easier kits to build, and results in a nice car. Buying an older, unfinished kit will save you a lot of money, and if the kit you're buying is missing parts, almost all of them are still common to Innovative's new kit. Often, when buying an unfinished kit, the VW pan has already been shortened and rebuilt...saving you even more money. Just make sure you have the chassis inspected by someone qualified, to ensure the frame is still square, and rewelded correctly. If you have any more questions, feel free to ask? Sincerely, Stephen 
|
meat
USA
992 Posts |
Posted - February 05 2003 : 10:50:31 PM
If you have never built a replica before, buying an S.E.P. abortion is just about absolutely the worst thing you could ever do. Anyone that would tell you otherwise - or encourage you to purchase something like this - is blowing smoke.There are a HUGE number of unfinished replicas out there. They are unfinished for a reason. And, when looking at an older kit from a company no longer in business, you will really not have any idea what you're looking at. CMC had a terrible reputation. Their kits can still be found - just about a decade after they went under - unfinished. Before I would even consider advising you on the purchase of an unfinished kit, I would need to know a bit more about your mechanical skills. If you've been turning wrenches on cars for years, you'll have a small idea of what to look for. But a kit car isn't anything like a car from a manufacturer. If you've never built - or helped someone build - a kit car, you really shouldn't even consider the purchase of a used kit. EVER. You will not be happy. Parts can get lost over the years sitting in a garage. If the kit has been sold more than once, then there are almost certainly missing parts. And who knows if the kit was even complete from the get go? Anyone who builds a replica understands that the trade off for getting a really cool and unique vehicle is that you're going to be putting in a great deal of sweat equity; a kit car isn't usually like buying a Honda. You don't go to a dealership and pick one up. You're not going to get all the parts. You're probably not going to get all the paperwork. You might not even be able to get the finished product registered. Anyone advising you to purchase a used kit - a used CMC kit at at - is giving out bad info. CMC had a bad rep. Innovative doesn't seem to be at all that different in their sales pitching than the previous company. Street Beasts called me back with special sales and 'close outs' just like CMC did. A company like that really doesn't need to be patronized. I do not and never will condone what CMC did to their customers, Curt Scott, and everyone else that was a victim of that company. I firmly believe that what they did was absolutely the worst thing that could have happened to the industry. I would strongly recommend finding any other company to do business with. As I mentioned before, Vintage Speedsters has an excellent product, and it's far more reasonably priced than the CMC/Innovative/Street Beasts product. The money you may save in purchasing the used CMC kit will probably all be spent buying parts from CMC. The amount of time you spend undoing what someone else may have done is going to probably double the amount of time it would have taken to finish a NEW kit from a REPUTABLE company. The cost of the used kit is secondary to the amount of time, sweat, tears and headaches that you'll have to endure by purchasing a USED kit. Stay away from a used kit, and look where the information is coming from before you make any purchase decision. Knowledge is power, research is key. Your pal, Meat. 
|
356FAN
USA
43 Posts |
Posted - February 06 2003 : 10:31:25 AM
First let me thank everyone who posted a response all of this information is wonderful.MEAT: The kit in question is actually for sale on this site (asking 7500 way to much)and my understanding is that it was never started. From the pictures it appears to be on the wood platform it shipped on. I agree that Vintage Speedsters in Hawaiian Gardens seems to have a decent kit and the price seems very good(I assume this is a kit your have built and where satisfied with the product they delivered). Assuming you have built this kit perhaps you can answer my question about the photo on there site of the box frame that appears to be a rolling chasse is this part of the kit similar to what street beasts is offering in that they provide a base frame to bolt VW suspension into. Stephenbl: Thanks for the link to Street Beasts I cant say that I have seen there site before but I like there approach to the frame issues. When you had built speedsters before where you using there kit(on the shortened VW) if so how did you find them to deal with as a company. Thanks again to all 356FAN 356FAN
|
stephenbl
64 Posts |
Posted - February 06 2003 : 6:35:09 PM
356 FAN, I tried, but couldn't find the ad for the car you're looking at on this site. First of all, it's good news that it's still in the crate. This means that, for whatever reason, it was never started on. So, nothing was done incorrectly(holes cut in the wrong place, etc). It's also very likely that the rest of the components are still in their boxes, reducing the likelyhood they were lost/damaged. It also means there isn't a chassis. This is o.k., but realize what you'll have to do...find a VW with a rustfree chassis, shorten it (or pay someone to do this for you), rebuilt the chassis (steering/suspension/engine,etc). Luckily, parts to rebuild the chassis are readily available, and the VW chassis is simple to rebuild. In my opinion, $7500.00 is too much for the car. You should be able to get one for much less than that. If you're interested in the kit, you should request to see a copy of the inventory sheet. On this, you'll see what options the car is supposed to have, and what was backordered...make sure they recieved the backordered parts...if not, you'll have to replace them. You should also do an inventory of what they have, using the inventory sheet. This will indicate any parts they may have lost. Every item the kit is missing should lower the price. Before you proceed, though, you should evaluate your abilities. The Speedster is one of the easier kits to assmeble, but it still requires a good mechanical knowledge. The kit should have an assembly manual(if not, make sure you can get one), but they often have "blurry" areas...their instructions may be unclear, or incomplete. You should have the mental knowledge and experience to overcome these problems. Don't expect this to be a model car, where you follow the directions, snap all the pieces together, and have a finished product. There may be areas where you will have to go without direction, be creative, and come up with a solution of your own. If the extent of your mechanical ability is to tune up a car, and install some simple aftermarket items, then you probably won't be able to finish the car. I'm not trying to discourage you, just trying to prevent you from having to sell your unfinished kit a few years from now. You'll also need more than your basic tools...you should have a well stocked shop. But, if you feel you're ready for the challenge, it can be a lot of fun. And you'll be very proud of the finished product. As for dealing with CMC. We rarely did. We assembled kits, we didn't purchase or sell them. Our customers often brought their kits to us to finish, after they gave up. Just as often, they bought a new kit, and had it shipped directly to us. Probably 70% of the kits we built were from CMC. The products CMC sold were good products. From what I heard, I didn't agree with their sales tactics. There were often back-ordered parts, but never anything major...usually small pieces, and they always showed up. Since Innovative took over things, I've heard things have really changed...but, I don't have any experience dealing with them. Talk to others that have purchased kits from them, and see what they think of them. As for other brands of Speedster kits, I don't have any experience with them...Intermeccanica has a good reputation, and it'd be nice having roll up windows, but the penalty is having a different windsheild...and they're pricey, too. In case you don't know what a VW chassis looks like without the VW body, I found a goos pic of one. I'll try to attach it. If I can answer any more of your questions, let me know! Stephen www.kitcar.com/york/yorkvwpan.jpg" border=0> 
|
stephenbl
64 Posts |
Posted - February 06 2003 : 6:36:10 PM
www.kitcar.com/york/yorkvwpan.jpg " border=0>
|
meat
USA
992 Posts |
Posted - February 06 2003 : 8:15:59 PM
Before you take advice from the above member, you really need to see the type of information and the lengths that this person will go to to obfuscate the truth.Your pal, Meat. 
|
meat
USA
992 Posts |
Posted - February 06 2003 : 8:20:35 PM
Check out this thread:http://kitcars.com/forums/topic.asp?ARCHIVE=&whichpage=2&TOPIC_ID=595 Pay particular attention to the post by stephenbl, posted February 06 2003 at 6:46:16 PM. It starts off with "Amazing!" and it's pretty much downhill from there. Is this the kind of information you want when you're looking at spending thousands of dollars out of your pocket? Your pal, Meat. 
|
meat
USA
992 Posts |
Posted - February 07 2003 : 07:46:39 AM
quote:
"...As for other brands of Speedster kits, I don't have any experience with them...Intermeccanica has a good reputation, and it'd be nice having roll up windows, but the penalty is having a different windsheild...and they're pricey, too..."
Say what? The Intermeccanica Speedster did not have roll-up windows, it had side curtaines and a windscreen exactly like the original Porsche Speedster did! Once again...know what you're talking about before you start offering up advice! Your pal, Meat. 
|
|